Home Freedom of Speech ACT success once again

ACT success once again

Author

Date

Category

Assisted dying will become legal in New Zealand in a year — what has to happen now?

By Andrew Geddis, Professor of Law, University of Otago

The preliminary results of New Zealand’s referendum on the End of Life Choice Act were conclusive. Some 65.2% of voters supported the law coming into force, while 33.8% opposed it.

Although around 480,000 special votes are still to be counted, the margin is so great there is no chance these will alter the final outcome. Consequently, the End of Life Choice Act 2019 will come into force on November 6 2021, one year after the official vote is announced next week.

It will then become lawful to offer assisted dying (AD) to terminally ill individuals who meet the legislation’s eligibility criteria. The delay in the law taking effect provides a 12-month window to implement the necessary arrangements for AD to take place.

One significant issue yet to be determined is whether AD services will be specifically funded, and if so how. The Ministry of Health will need to resolve this over the next year.

In the meantime, what needs to happen next? Immediate priorities for the Director-General of Health under the legislation are:

  • to appoint a Registrar (assisted dying)
  • to establish the Support and Consultation for End of Life in New Zealand (SCENZ) Group
  • to appoint an End of Life Review Committee.

The role of the Registrar (assisted dying)

The Registrar (assisted dying) plays a core role in monitoring and reporting on compliance with the Act. They will also direct any complaints about AD to the appropriate bodies.

The Act, administered by the Ministry of Health, requires adherence to strict regulatory processes. These must be documented in prescribed forms submitted to the Registrar before AD may be performed.

Approving and issuing these prescribed forms falls to the Director-General of Health.

What SCENZ will do

Curiously, the Act does not prescribe the composition of the SCENZ Group. It simply requires that the Director-General appoint members with the necessary knowledge and understanding to perform its functions.

The group essentially has two roles:

  • to determine standards of care and advise on the required medical and legal procedures for the administration of medication for AD
  • to provide practical assistance if requested.

The second role is largely administrative and facilitative. SCENZ is required to curate and maintain a list of health practitioners willing to be involved in AD, which includes:

  • doctors willing to act as replacement medical practitioners should a person’s own doctor be unwilling to participate in AD due to conscientious objection
  • medical practitioners willing to provide an independent second opinion on a person’s eligibility for AD
  • psychiatrists willing to provide specialist opinions on a person’s capacity, should either or both the attending or independent medical practitioners not be satisfied that the person requesting AD is competent
  • pharmacists willing to dispense the necessary drugs.

Given these functions, the SCENZ group will presumably be comprised of suitably qualified medical practitioners and pharmacists as well as individuals with knowledge of the relevant law and tikanga Māori, although its final composition remains to be seen.

Compliance and review

The Director-General of Health must also appoint a three-person End of Life Review Committee. This body is tasked with evaluating reports of assisted deaths to determine if the statutory requirements are being complied with. It can refer cases to the Registrar if it is not satisfied.

The Act requires the committee to be comprised of one ethicist and two health practitioners, one of whom must be practising end-of-life care.

Role of the Medical Council

Given the medical profession will have primary responsibility for providing AD, it’s likely its professional body, the Medical Council of New Zealand, will need to begin formulating and consulting on clinical practice standards for medical practitioners involved in providing or facilitating AD.

While the council publishes generic standards of professional practice, including standards for obtaining informed consent and cultural safety, specific guidance should be developed for AD.

The standards should incorporate the legal obligations imposed on medical practitioners under the Act. These include the prohibition on initiating a discussion of AD with a patient, and the legal obligation to inform a patient of their right to a replacement medical practitioner if their doctor objects to AD.

 

The Medical Council could also provide guidance on clinical practice issues that may arise, including ways of identifying coercion, or how to manage difficult conversations with patients (such as when they are found to be ineligible under the Act).

Objection and obligation

Significantly, the Act doesn’t require health institutions to provide AD services. Hospice New Zealand has already signalled it will not provide AD, as it is contrary to its philosophy “neither to hasten nor to postpone death”.

However, a recent High Court decision notes that although institutions may choose not to provide AD, medical practitioners will still be required to discharge their obligations under the Act — including the obligation to provide information to patients.

Although an organisation may elect not to provide AD, it may employ medical practitioners who are willing to. Provisions will need to be made to enable such practitioners to provide AD outside their own organisation. This is an area that will require careful navigation.

Having that toady Bloomfield as DG and being in charge, doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence that he will do this correctly.

11 COMMENTS

    • H P, if it hadn’t been for D S we wouldn’t have even got a chance to vote on it, the pressure on him was enormous and he did make changes to the original bill but we now have a choice and choice is a good thing…

      6

      0

  1. I voted for it but disappointed the process to become eligible means you’d probably be dead before completing all the hoops the terminally ill person has to jump through.

    At least Act can get stuff done and reads the will of the people.

    5

    0

  2. All the empty end of life care facilities can be turned into homes for the homeless, despite all the B/S from the opposition to this new law in reality it all came down to the same old thing FOLLOW THE MONEY..
    We are encouraged throughout life to “take responsibility” for ourselves so why should it be any different when it comes to dying with dignity when life has become unbearable due to pain and suffering ???

    3

    0

    • Apparently, in Canada the health care costs have dropped markedly since this law was introduced. Read it somewhere a few days ago.

      0

      0

    • I don’t think shooting the old dears was ever in the brochure. Far less sexy, and the referendum may have failed. I don’t imagine the nurses are any better shots than the police (who get a day at the range every year), so there could be some munted wheelchairs as well.

      0

      0

Comments are closed.

Recent posts

WTF is systemic racism?

Systemic racism at heart of New Zealand’s council Maori wards debate – advocate Susan Botting from Stuff: Systemic racism is at the heart of New Zealand’s...

Putting People First

The Great Reset after COVID-19 must put people first Amol Mehra COVID-19 has exposed many underlying structural and institutional inequalities. • Social movements are pushing for action...

No wonder the Dems are running scared

Trump Pushing to Revive Firing Squads and Electrocution as Feds Ramp Up Executions By Elias Marat: While the final 50 days of a president’s tenure are...

Recent comments

Sooty on Have Your Say
Sooty on Have Your Say
Chuck Bird on Have Your Say
Simpleton1 on Have Your Say
Falcon on Have Your Say
Simpleton1 on Have Your Say
Odakyu-sen on Have Your Say
Odakyu-sen on Have Your Say

The way we all feel about this useless government

Hamilton
overcast clouds
14.1 ° C
14.4 °
13.9 °
86 %
4.5kmh
89 %
Sun
14 °
Mon
18 °
Tue
21 °
Wed
23 °
Thu
19 °
NZD - New Zealand Dollar
USD
1.4248
EUR
1.7046
AUD
1.0525
CAD
1.0964
GBP
1.8960
JPY
0.0137
CNY
0.2166
INR
0.0193