HomeUncategorisedLiabour screwing with elections

Liabour screwing with elections




Govt wants independent watchdog to keep eye on election campaign policy costings

The creation of an independent entity to make sure political parties aren’t fudging their figures in election campaigns is a step closer.

Cabinet has recommended that the Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) is given the status of an Officer of Parliament – which would mean it is completely independent and non-partisan, like the Ombudsmen or Auditor-General.

The problem of political parties disputing each others costing was highlighted in the 2017 election, when the former National Party MP Steven Joyce claimed Labour had an $11 billion fiscal hole.

The PBO is designed to monitor the government’s fiscal strategy as well as provide independent costings of political party policies.

Finance Minister Grant Robertson said the PBO was in the interest of both political parties and the public.

“This is common place around the world, we’re actually catching up with the rest of the world in having this kind of office,” he said.

The current proposal would mean someone who got three percent or more of the vote in the last election would be able to access the service.

The PBO’s creation is part of the Green Party’s confidence and supply agreement.

Associate Finance Minister James Shaw said the independent budget office would mean more transparency about what political parties were promising to do and fewer political games played.

The proposal has been put to to the Officers of Parliament Committee, chaired by Speaker Trevor Mallard, to reach a consensus.

It will make its decision in the coming weeks.

National says government ‘screwing the scrum’

National Party Leader Simon Bridges said he would oppose it every step of the way, because he doesn’t trust the government.

“They want to illegitimately, undemocratically screw the scrum on the opposition,” Mr Bridges said.

He said he felt that way because he had asked for a Treasury official to help with costing and economic policies and holding the government to account.

“I feel like we have been obstructed from the get go. If they won’t even supply me with a secondee at the opposition’s own cost, how can I trust them with a supposedly independent institution?”

It’s understood while there was a delay for National to be offered a Treasury Official but when one was offered, National rejected the person, saying they weren’t what it was looking for.

Mr Robertson said he was extremely disappointed Mr Bridges didn’t want more transparency.

He said if the proposal didn’t get the approval of the committee, the government would look at other possible options.

Previous article
Next article


    • Twitford in the House yesterday was taking the mick out of Bridges for all the things he didn’t trust:
      Lost me in gales of laughter when the first thing he said Simon didn’t trust was Statistics.
      Only a weapons grade idiot ….



  1. I back Simon Bridges on this. I do not have confidence in Minister Robertson’s ability to run such a matter equitably or to protect the thoughts of the opposition from being purloined by the government or its enablers.

    It is a green desire we are told. There is another reason to ignore it as reasonable.

    Keeping government lean and working only for value for taxpayers in providing essentials necessary to operate means this proposal is a nonsense. Taxpayers can readily figure what is tosh. We have plenty of examples to consider with the current government. How is Kiwibuild going for example. Any progress at pike River? Are more working groups needed?

    Simon is right.



Recent posts

Have Your Say

Stop Immigration

Have Your Say

Recent comments

I am a stupid boy on Have Your Say
I am a stupid boy on Have Your Say
I am a stupid boy on Have Your Say
FJA on Have Your Say
I am a stupid boy on Have Your Say
Viking on Have Your Say
Sooty on Have Your Say
Sooty on Have Your Say

Pike is our weekly review of the most popular posts and comments seen on YSB in the past week.
broken clouds
12.9 ° C
13.9 °
12.9 °
86 %
55 %
18 °
22 °
23 °
22 °
20 °
NZD - New Zealand Dollar