Home NZ Politics Lying Twitford

Lying Twitford




Phil Twyford repeatedly ‘forgot’ key NZTA job offer, until he couldn’t

Stuff report

Fucked up Kiwibuild, fucked up NZTA . Time for Cindy to step up.

Minister of Transport Phil Twyford has said repeatedly that the former board of the New Zealand Transport Agency – with which he had a fractious relationship – did not wish to be reappointed and that the replacement of all but one of the board members last month was due to the board’s term ending. 

But now sources have confirmed to Stuff that this was in fact not the case and that some board members did ask to be reappointed, raising questions over whether Twyford misled Parliament. 

Last week, Twyford was asked in Parliament by National Party Transport spokesman Chris Bishop whether he would “stand by his statement that no one on the New Zealand Transport Agency board asked to stay on?”

Twyford responded, “Yes, I do”. 

In response to questions from Stuff, Twyford has now changed his story.

“When the Minister answered Chris Bishop’s question in the House – which was a supplementary question not on notice – his recollection was that no one had offered to stay on”, a spokeswoman for Twyford said.

“He [Twyford] remembered that he had asked Mark Darrow [a former board member] to stay on the board temporarily in the interests of continuity” the spokeswoman said.

“The Minister has now had a chance to review his correspondence from May and see that, in response to his request, Mark Darrow had said he would be interested in staying on for a second term”.

“The Minister will correct the answer in the House at the first opportunity'” the spokeswoman said.

But sources told Stuff that other board members were also approached about being reappointed.

Twyford’s spokeswoman hung up the phone when asked why Darrow wasn’t reappointed if Twyford had asked him, and he wanted to be on the NZTA board.

Twyford’s recollection on the matter has repeatedly failed him on this point. He also confirmed to Stuff in September that no one on the board expressed a preference to stay on. Asked whether any board members asked or wanted to stay on, Twyford said on September 19 that, “no, everyone had reached the end of their terms”.

Twyford had said the board was “refreshed and refocused” in September when he announced that all bar one of its previous members would be leaving the board.

The revelation comes after several damaging leaks published in Stuff showed a massive falling out between Twyford and his former board over the Auckland light rail project.

The Government had initially wanted NZTA to build the multi-billion dollar project, but apparently soured on the idea after the NZ Super Fund made an unsolicited bid to build the project itself.

NZTA thought the bid was “vague” and lacked merit, and pushed on with its own plans, which Twyford put a stop to nearly a year later.

Leaked letters from the former NZTA board show board members’ frustration that Twyford appeared to blame the lack of progress for light rail on the NZTA. The board alleges that it was Twyford’s indecision that delayed the project. 

Sir Brian Roche, the current chair of NZTA and the only member of the old board still at NZTA, went in to bat for the minister last week, saying the Agency “dropped the ball”.

It also appears Twyford has struggled to fill the board with new appointees. David Smol was among those who left the board in August, but the agency’s website still lists him as a board member.

At the time of the board ructions, Twyford was only able to fill five of the seven vacancies opened by the former members. It appears Smol may have now filled one of the two vacancies leaving one remaining. 

Bishop said Twyford had “serious questions to answer”. 

“He is on the record in Parliament saying that nobody on the New Zealand Transport Agency board asked to stay on the board, and he’s now being contradicted by multiple people and has serious questions to answer,” Bishop said. 

Previous articleHave Your Say
Next articleThanks National


  1. What are the people of NZ paying this total incompetent for? And now he is blatantly lying in the House to cover up his wonky decision making. Twiford sacked the board because he was looking bad. Cindy needs to sack wonky Phail from his ministry but she won’t. Wonky Cindy has no replacement in the useless wonky COL.



  2. I am always puzzled when people act surprised when once again members of this coalition are exposed as being dishonest which in my opinion is also an indicator of corruption as well as incompetence.

    The current coalition of labour, the watermelons and “what’s in it for wynston” has shown itself to be the worst government we have ever had in New Zealand and their lying needs to be highlighted every day.



  3. As a citizen I am not at all worried that this Minister failed with the Kiwibuild nonsense and the half baked Auckland rail proposals.

    I did not wish to pay tax for any of it. We paid to home our family over the years by hard work and sacrifice. We have paid to get to and from work without requiring subsidy from other taxpayers.

    I used to watch question time having given up for the meantime due to the volume of dumb patsy questions from members of the government to their ministers. One of those who I saw responding to questions was Minister Twyford.

    I struggled then to see how he got to that Ministerial position. I saw obfuscation and distraction along with seeming non ending blame on the previous administration. He was not convincing for me. That Kiwibuild required a refocus was not a surprise.

    My view is he should step down.



    • He had “dickhead” written across his face from day One. CEO of Kiwibuild jumps the sinking ship very quickly. Twyford’s 10-second pause when asked why on national TV said it all. He was sweating bullets. The CEO did not want his reputation trashed by a hair-brained scheme. Twyford says “it’s not my job to know blah blah”. A more pathetic worm of a politician would be difficult to find!



  4. Twyford should be called Xerox.
    Everywhere he goes he copies what he did previously
    — lies and massive incompetence delivered with great hubris.

    I dealt with the twat in 1996 and he was the same then when he was with dodgy Oxfam.
    This chinky names caller does not change its spots.



Recent posts

Oh Dear, How Sad, Never Mind.

Man Who Had His Sex Organs Removed During Gender Reassignment Surgery Sues NHS A British man who had his genitals removed during gender reassignment surgery...

What Next?

This nuclear-powered ‘flying cruise ship’ could stay airborne for years at a time, carrying 5,000 guests Forget brief trips to space. A nuclear-powered flying hotel...

Man is man and woman is woman

Some appear to have difficulty in defining a woman, why— It is very simple. A WOMAN: a member of the Homo sapiens species having two...

Recent comments

Rachael Membery on Have Your Say
Ross12 on Have Your Say
waikatogirl on Have Your Say
nasska on Have Your Say
Beorn on Have Your Say
waikatogirl on Have Your Say
waikatogirl on Have Your Say
Leofric on Have Your Say

The way we all feel about this useless government

clear sky
8.5 ° C
9 °
6.7 °
98 %
3 %
8 °
14 °
14 °
14 °
13 °
NZD - New Zealand Dollar