The leaflet that turned up in my letterbox reads like a lesson in how MMP works. It’s really an attempt to protect National’s list MPs.
National’s plan to fix the basics and build the future. To create a more secure future for all New Zealanders. National PARTY VOTE
YOUR PARTY VOTE IS THE KEY VOTE. Under MMP, only your party vote decides the government. Your electorate vote does not. If you want National to lead the next government, it’s crucial to give your party vote to National.
Why the only safe strategic vote is to party vote National. Under MMP, you get two votes – a party vote and an electorate vote. Only the party vote decides who has the numbers to form a government. Your electorate vote chooses your local MP. So if you want National to continue leading the government, your party vote must go to National. Here’s why: • Keep a strong, stable coalition. Giving your party vote to another party – even one National may work with – makes it harder for National to be the largest party. National is the key to a strong, stable, successful coalition. • Keep National’s hardworking team. Without your party vote, there will be fewer National MPs elected and fewer talented National ministers. Don’t risk losing National’s high performers. • Keep the chaos out. In a tight election race, giving your party vote to any other party increases the risk of Labour forming a government with the Greens, Te Pāti Māori and TOP. With nine new taxes on the table between these parties, you and New Zealand simply cannot afford to take that risk. Don’t risk a Labour-led government. Party vote National.

I’ve given National my party vote for years without much thought. This year I won’t, and a pamphlet telling me my electorate vote doesn’t decide the government isn’t going to change my mind. Under MMP that claim gives the game away. It only holds up if you ignore a rule that National is clearly worried its own supporters have started to notice.
Each of your two votes has its own job. The party vote decides how many of the standard 120 seats each qualifying party gets. The electorate vote picks your local MP. When a party wins more electorates than its share of the party vote entitles it to, it keeps all of those MPs, gets no list MPs, and Parliament gets bigger to fit them in. The extra seats are called an overhang, and no other party loses seats because of it. Nobody dreamed this up on a blog. It happens whenever a party’s electorate wins outrun its party vote, which is how we ended up with 123 MPs after the 2023 election.
On this campaign’s polling, National is already at the point where an extra party vote won’t produce an extra National MP, or close to it. One reading of the Taxpayers’ Union–Curia poll gave National about 40 of the 120 seats, and it currently holds 44 electorates. If it keeps those seats, there’s no room left for anyone off its list. Another party vote for National just tops up a share its electorate MPs have already used, and the coalition gets no extra MP out of it. Give that same vote to ACT or New Zealand First instead, both still winning list seats and both above the threshold in current polls, and you get two results from one ballot. National still has its local MP, and its partner picks up a list MP. If enough voters split their votes this way, National’s party-vote share drops even further below its electorate tally and Parliament grows. Oliver Hartwich’s modelling made the point bluntly. If roughly one in nine National party voters switched to a coalition partner, the government could end up with a majority even if the opposition won more votes overall.
The leaflet calls that strategy unsafe. Don Brash has said that if the right used it, nobody could beat them. Nick Mowbray, who has donated to both National and ACT, has said the goal is simply to give the current coalition the best chance of carrying on. National won’t endorse any of it, which isn’t surprising. An overhang is good for the bloc and bad for the people on National’s list.
Go back to the mailer with that in mind. “Keep National’s hardworking team.” “Don’t risk losing National’s high performers.” Those lines have nothing to do with the country and everything to do with who’s where on the list. Nicola Willis is near the top and has no electorate to fall back on. Behind her are Chris Bishop and Paul Goldsmith, whose seats aren’t safe. Gerry Brownlee is ninth, and if there’s a real overhang he’d be one of the first “high performers” to find out the list doesn’t reach him. The authorisation line on the pamphlet names the party secretary, but the people who are actually worried are the ones who can only get back into Parliament on your party vote.

Three years in, it’s fair to judge them on their record. Willis took over finance promising to restore discipline and deliver the relief voters were promised in 2023. Households are still waiting for that relief, despite all the press releases. Bishop was supposed to be the minister who’d finally get houses built and sort out the planning system. Goldsmith was going to put victims ahead of the court processes that have clogged up justice for a decade. Brownlee was made Speaker to keep order in the House, and he spent the term fending off accusations that he applied one set of rules to his own side and another to everyone else. By the final sitting block he looked like someone reading the rulebook for the first time on his way out the door. If this is the team we can’t afford to lose, the bar for “high performer” is very low.
The leaflet’s other warning is that a party vote for anyone else makes a Labour, Greens, Te Pāti Māori and TOP government more likely, along with whatever taxes they’d agree on. That argument would carry weight if the alternative were throwing your vote away, but it isn’t. ACT and New Zealand First are already in government with National. Electing one more MP from that bloc, while National keeps every one of its electorate MPs, doesn’t help the left at all. It makes the majority they need to beat bigger. National’s own wording gives it away when it says a vote for a partner “makes it harder for National to be the largest party.” That’s harder for National, not for a National-led government, and the party seems to think those are the same thing.
I’m not a big fan of either partner, but nobody is perfect. New Zealand First’s plan to buy the BNZ back from NAB is nostalgia with a price tag nobody could actually pay, and ACT will use any extra MPs to push policies that plenty of long-time National voters are lukewarm about at best. Voting for the overhang doesn’t mean signing up to everything either party stands for. It just means accepting that the two votes do different things. In a safe National seat, the local candidate will win without your party vote, but the list candidates are relying on it. After three years of broken promises, I’m not going to use the vote that decides the size of Parliament to protect a list order Willis, Bishop, Goldsmith and Brownlee drew up for themselves.

My plan is to give my party vote to one of National’s partners and my electorate vote to National. The leaflet calls that chaos, but all it does is use the overhang rule that National would rather you didn’t know about.
And then I get this from my X feed:
John Key debated Harry Mowbray on the overhang strategy live this morning on the Platform, and came off second best.
National really are determined to lose the election rather than cede more power to NZF & Act. A deflated sounding Key admits the overhang strategy will work BUT only if enough people know about it …. Key is stuck in 2008, today we are all on Social Media – a political message can now be mobilised to MILLIONS in just days.
Keys other argument is “If this strategy works, I mean we will end up with a much stronger NZF and Act, and Winston as PM… more Winston means less India Free trade deal!” -Don’t threaten us with a good time Johnny boy!
Harry calmly handles Key, “ We only need 10% of voters to use the strategy and we will grow the already occurring 4 seat overhang to 10, and guarantee the centre right win, I cannot understand why you won’t embrace it ?”
An off balance Key then resorts to attacking WP and finishes by praising Luxon and rating him as a 10/10 Prime minister..” with that comment Key just lost all credibility – Luxon is deeply unpopular with the right, he is hopelessly out of touch, weak and arrogant – and because of that he’s collapsed Nationals party vote which will unleash the left on NZ – unless we :
Electorate vote: National
Party Vote: NZF or Act
Listen here https://x.com/2ETEKA/status/2107958845960249755?s=20
Then I got this:
From Ashley Church – I decided to test this
proposition in a simple poll –
asking respondents whether
they intended to give their list vote to Nats & their
party vote to ACT or NZ First. it’s not a scientific poll – my followers are CR voters. Voters have got the message

Things are looking good for the right afterall.
Simple poll
Are you going to be smart and use this overhang idea?
Uptick yes
Downtick no
Poll doesn’t mean much here. I think you’re preaching to the choir.
It’s good to know the choir are ALL singing from the same song sheet.
Just now got to decide between Act and NZ1st. Winston did say this:
“He should be behind bars explaining why he poisoned people”
I agree the pinko sausage roll eater, should be in prison.
I have always done this, it is mmp. If nats want good people win the electorate vote the party vote is for you coalition partner.
In an overwhelming blue seat, it would seem I have much more often in sense split my vote.
The only exception was when my vote went to Bill English National Party & that was because Winston Peters said he would go into coalition with the party with the largest vote.
Even then my electorate vote would have been contrary to the sitting National Party electorate seat.
Last election a feisty independent that split from the National Party, that I saw if he got some numbers would give a message to the sitting National Party candidate.
Am not going to vote in the simple poll as I am not changing my vote away from National, I already do that.
It is quite clear that the “overhang” vote is quite clearly understood by readers of YSB, Kiwiblog, Brash & Mitchell articles and probably Whale Oil/Good Oil blog.
But for all that overall that is a very small room full of right side voters amongst a Country full that voted 38.08 % National last election. Is the message getting through, NO.
The last Taxpayers Curia poll has National 28.5 ACT 9.2 down 1.3% and NZF 12%, up 3.6%. Certainly the push has overall in the blogs more to ACT and not NZF. Winston in his normal way knows how to put out enough vote catcher ideas to gather in support before any election.
That poll has the right at which to my adding is 49.7 – presumably its share of the “wasted” vote will just push it over 50%. However without the National overhang bit with the Maori overhang more is needed.
With National pushing the Party vote I fear that a major shift to ACT or NZF by voters following the overhang vote strategy is not going to happen.
Fire this around to people you know if it helps:
https://splityourvote.co.nz/
Do you think the losing parties will want a look into how people voted!
Four year terms, vote splitting, dickhead candidates etc.
Reading this for the umteenth time, the thought crossed my mind, what if National got such a low party vote, and became one of the “minor parties” of the three centre right ones, what’s to stop them forming a centre left govt with liarbour? National have more in common with liarbour than ACT or New Zealand First.
Given their level of hatred for Winston, any thing is possible.
A uniparty would please their WEF masters that Hipkins, Luxon and more MP’s of both parties support.
Damn Skippy, lets make the Natz a minor party in the center right coalition, punish them for their road blocks and show them there is consequence’s for promising one thing then not delivering on anything.
The idea of a combined ‘Nats Labour ‘coalition’ isn’t new and was being hypothesised prior to the last election, with some even suggesting at the time that should such a ‘coalition’ occur, it was highly-likely that the parties-concerned would merge, creating some sort of ‘Super party’ (‘Lants? Nabour?) which would dominate NZ politics for at least two elections before being kicked out by disillusioned voters.
So far it hasn’t happened, but with National and Labour both definitely declining in popularity; ‘Desperation’ may make the hypothesis real.
We live in ‘interesting’ times.
We live in ‘interesting’ times
Thats a Chinese curse
I suspect if that happened, voters from both sides would punish them at the next election, with Act/ NZ1st and the Greens/TOP benefitting from the revolt.
Once Winston dies the NZFirst party will transform into a party to be trusted by right voters.
Being in the Whangarei electorate I always vote National and always given my party vote to ACT. Will be doing the same this time. Quite frankly National don’t deserve any party votes, they have become wetter and wetter and progressively more woke. Losing the likes of Goldsmith, Brownlie, Willis and Bishop will do them no harm at all.
That pamphlet is the epitomy of mis-information . No doubt the media will be calling them out on it////
I just cannot understand Key & co. After 30 + years they still do not understand MMP.
They should have put their thinking caps on 2 years ago when it was clear Luxon was leading them into this position. By Luxon and Willis showing no backbone there was only one result that would happen.
Is John Keys going senile? Has he lost the plot?