HomeLeftie StupidityProfessionals More Likely To Be Unethical

Professionals More Likely To Be Unethical

Author

Date

Category

People who see themselves as ‘professional’ are actually more likely to behave unethically

John Anderer

Are “professionals” more likely to act unprofessionally? New research by a team from Cornell University is shedding some light on the connection between someone thinking they display “professionalism” and their tendency to bend the rules whenever it’s convenient. Scientists conclude managers and employees who consider themselves professional are actually more vulnerable to committing conflicts of interest in the workplace.

In more scientific terms, the study reports safeguards from bias fail much more often among members of the workforce with a particularly high personal self-concept of professionalism.

“I noticed that many professional advisors, such as financial advisors and physicians, claim that their ‘professionalism’ protects them from corruption and unwanted influence from conflicts of interest; that they can ‘manage their own brains,’” explains study author, Sunita Sah, associate professor of management and organizations at the Samuel Curtis Johnson Graduate School of Management, in a university release. “However, a large body of social science research shows that much bias from conflicts of interests is unintentional and implicit, and claims of professionalism and integrity do little to protect against unwanted influence.”

More vulnerable to quid pro quo

Prof. Suh interviewed 400 managers and asked about a variety of conflict-of-interest scenarios. For each hypothetical situation, each manager had to either accept or reject the relevant gift offered in each scenario. Moreover, the participants also had to imagine accepting these gifts. Then, the group had to consider if the gift would hold any sway over them regarding future company decisions.

Before beginning these exercises, all participants had their perceived levels of professionalism measured. The team accomplished this by measuring each person’s predictions on how well they can prioritize objectivity over everything else and self-regulate unwanted influence.

“Consistent with my predictions, the greater the managers’ sense of professionalism, the more likely they were to report that they would accept gifts from people with questionable or ambiguous agendas, and less likely to be influenced by the specific gifts in the scenarios,” Prof. Sah writes. “These overall results indicate that a high sense of professionalism with a shallow understanding of the concept may lead to greater acceptance of conflicts and potentially more bias.”

More education can keep managers in check

At one time, study authors note that “professionalism” was a word largely synonymous with important fields like law and medicine. Now, Prof. Sah says the word has evolved into a full-blown concept referring to how people conduct themselves at work across a variety of fields.

“I propose that professionalism be redefined not as an individual characteristic or feeling, but as a set of observable repeated behavioral practices that demonstrates a deep understanding of the concept and promotes outcomes in the interest of clients and the societal good,” Prof. Sah continues. “Policies and rules need to be combined with positive role models who model deep professionalism and provide education – nurturing virtues of thought – along with opportunities to practice – nurturing virtues of character.”

In conclusion, Prof. Sah theorizes the concept of deep professionalism may one day become a common topic of study at business schools across the country.

“Managers could commit to continuing education and practice to remain competent and ethical,” she concludes. “Efforts to progress one’s cognitive moral development and empathy would help in understanding one’s limitations and fallibilities. Greater humility and the ability to articulate and acknowledge doubts in relation to [conflicts of interests] and other ethical problems is critical to developing and maintaining an ethical self.”

Previous article
Next article

6 COMMENTS

  1. I resigned from the Institute of Chartered Accountants after the accountancy profession morphed into the accounting industry.
    There was no place for a professional like me amongst the industrialists.
    I criticised the annual financial statements of a local chartered club as they were the biggest mish mash of meaningless mumbo jumbo that I had seen. The apologetic response I got was that the accounts complied with modern accounting policies and I was out of date!!!

    8

    0

  2. I think the key phrase is the second title “People who see themselves as ‘professional’ are actually more likely to behave unethically”, and the active words “See themselves as ‘professional’.”

    Corruption happens at all levels, blue collar, white collar, it is just that white collar are in control of bigger funds / value, and have more societal impact or influence, so in many cases it only appears that “Professionals More Likely To Be Unethical”. With power comes responsibility, and lack of responsibility thereof is corruption.

    The potential for the corruption however, is in everyone, except that principled people acknowledge the potential exists but never act upon it. Except for those principled people, the only thing that stops other people from straying from the right path in general, is the lack of means and opportunity, and the possibility of being caught.

    Corruption is accompanied by hubris, lack of humility, no mental self-inspection, and no objectivity.
    And one of the visible signs of someone predestined for corruption is a sense of being self-entitled.

    People with all those character flaws are not professionals. They are simply self-entitled imposters.
    As an example, any MP who was professional would have resigned, walked out of parliament, and joined the protesters, That no-one has, shows lack of a complete lack of professional character and/or the degree to which blackmail has been employed to keep everyone’s mouth shut.

    6

    0

Recent posts

Tuesday Fun

Have Your Say

Mad Bill Doesn’t Like Memes

Have Your Say

Recent comments

The Ancient Hooligan on Have Your Say
Starving Artist on Have Your Say
The Ancient Hooligan on Have Your Say
Brian Marshall on Have Your Say
Simpleton1 on Have Your Say
Tarquin on Have Your Say
Simpleton1 on Have Your Say
Editor on Have Your Say

Pike is our weekly review of the most popular posts and comments seen on YSB in the past week.
Hamilton
overcast clouds
19.4 ° C
19.4 °
18.5 °
92 %
3.2kmh
100 %
Mon
19 °
Tue
23 °
Wed
25 °
Thu
27 °
Fri
25 °
NZD - New Zealand Dollar
USD
1.6137
EUR
1.7482
AUD
1.0578
CAD
1.1965
GBP
2.0460
JPY
0.0107
CNY
0.2243
INR
0.0195