Home Freedom of Speech Speaking the truth

Speaking the truth

Author

Date

Category

A teacher sent us this guide to teaching sixth formers about racism and inequality in the wake of George Floyd’s death and the Black Lives Matter protests and we thought it was so good we’ve decided to publish it. Teaching schoolchildren about these politically-charged issues in a balanced, fair-minded way is hard, not least because if you depart from the orthodoxies of the BLM movement you risk losing your job. To cite just one example, a headteacher at a school in Vermont called Tiffany Riley was removed from her job after she questioned some of the tactics of BLM activists on Facebook. Yet it is important to try nonetheless. Children should be encouraged to think critically about these issues and not succumb to group-think or, worse, publicly shame those who refuse to go along with the crowd. As the author of this guide says in the introduction, “Almost all politicians, journalists, academics and other public figures agree that racism is an evil that should have no place in our society, and that we must do everything we can to fight it. Yet there is also great disagreement about how to identify racism, the causes of inequalities between groups, and the right solutions for tackling racism.”

For any teachers drawn to these materials, but nervous about using them in their classrooms – perhaps because their school or college has enthusiastically endorsed the BLM movement – it’s worth remembering that schools have a legal duty to teach children about politics in a balanced way under the Education Act 1996. Section 406 prohibits “the promotion of partisan political views in the teaching of any subject in the school” and s.407 says that “where political issues are brought to the attention of pupils” they should be “offered a balanced presentation of opposing views”. There can be no doubt that the BLM movement and the views of its members are political. It is a self-professed Marxist organisation that, among other things, wants to dismantle capitalism. Its supporters believe that the police and the criminal justice system is systemically racist, that the UK owes its wealth to the slave trade and colonialism and that racism is by far the biggest cause of racial inequality in contemporary Britain. Those are perfectly legitimate points of view and a wealth of evidence can be marshalled in their support. But there is an equally legitimate alternative point of view which maintains that the criminal justice system isn’t racist, that the slave trade and colonialism made a negligible contribution to the UK’s economic success and that racism is a cause of racial inequality, but not the only cause and not the most significant one. Plenty of evidence can be marshalled to support that point of view, too. If teachers are going to broach these issues in the classroom, they have a legal duty to present both sides of the argument to children, not just echo the views of the protestors.

What we like about this guide is that the teacher who’s compiled it has clearly made an effort to be scrupulously fair-minded and to remain as neutral as possible in what must be the most heated debate of the moment, introducing children to the most articulate advocates on both sides. Of course, for some partisans, neutrality means you’re siding with the enemy – that if you refuse to endorse every jot and tittle of the BLM narrative you are complicit in the systemic racism that’s disfiguring the lives of black Britons. We reject that. We believe it’s possible to teach children about racism and racial inequality in a way that doesn’t affirm all the claims of the BLM movement and, at the same time, isn’t remotely racist. This is a complex subject and one we believe all good teachers who teach this subject have a duty to convey in a fair and balanced way – not just a legal duty, but a professional one too.

Previous articleAngry here as well?
Next articleHave Your Say

5 COMMENTS

  1. BLM
    Anthropogenic Climate Change

    When there are two sides to an arguement, I am more likely to oppose the side which:
    – Distributes emails encouraging its followers to lie
    – Does not present testable hypotheses or facts
    – Has an (obvious) hidden agenda
    – Has a history of unlawful violence
    – Appeals to feelz
    – Uses bullying tactics
    – Threatens violence to deplatform speeches by the opposition
    – Attacks and slanders opponents
    – Attacks and slanders opponents’ family members
    – Has leaders who self-profess that they follow an ideology of an enemy regime

    By their actions (not their words) you shall know them.

    10

    0

    • How are the BLM riots, looting, murders, arson and rapes going in Japan?

      Given the high levels of racism directed at Asians. Including from the Ardern regime.

      4

      1

      • There were pro-BLM protests in Tokyo, but not the looting, murders, arson and rapes
        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-KCsupQLyRs

        I think this is a fad that the Japanese public doesn’t care about too much. I am sure that it would be supported by the Japanese Communist Party and any number of the radical left groups in Japan.
        It would be so fashionable to participate in such a rally in Tokyo and rub shoulders with the gaijin.

        6

        0

        • As I expected. Privileged urban malcontents are a universal problem.

          Pol Pot was right about that much.

          3

          0

  2. Just about any political, social ad environmental movement I can think of looks only at a part of the whole picture. That is their weakness and why they fail and descend to tribal fighting and mindless dogma.
    We are a tribal species.

    0

    0

Comments are closed.

Recent posts

Dumb and Dumber

What do Victoria and New Zealand have in common? Robert Carling: Victoria and New Zealand are similar in size and population. Their current leaders, Premier and...

Tax cuts are sexist!

The Morrison government’s planned tax cuts will benefit high-income earners and most high-income earners are men. You know where this is going, don’t you. Yes,...

Flying Cars

Japan May Have Flying Cars In Three Years A Japanese tech startup, the Tokyo-based company SkyDrive, now says it plans to launch the first commercial...

Recent comments

Sooty on Have Your Say
waikatogirl on Dumb and Dumber
revtech120 on Have Your Say
Viking on Have Your Say
waikatogirl on Have Your Say
Editor on Have Your Say
freethinker on Flying Cars
waikatogirl on Have Your Say

The way we all feel about this useless government

Hamilton
clear sky
8.8 ° C
10 °
7.2 °
91 %
4kmh
0 %
Fri
13 °
Sat
15 °
Sun
16 °
Mon
17 °
Tue
17 °
NZD - New Zealand Dollar
USD
1.4774
EUR
1.7515
AUD
1.0791
CAD
1.1196
GBP
1.9107
JPY
0.0141
CNY
0.2183
INR
0.0201