Home Leftie Stupidity We Are Not Alone: Open Letter from an American.

We Are Not Alone: Open Letter from an American.




By Sarah Chamberlain.

I am an American, a New Hampshire woman, a lover of liberty, and a happily married mother of four beautiful children. I have a wonderful life, a bright future, and could not ask for any greater blessing than those I have already received.

My enemies are in a word, communists. Modern communists do not usually call themselves such. They do not talk about workers rising up and seizing the Means of Production.

Instead, modern communists adopt a rhetorical stance where they assume that all people and all property are ALREADY COLLECTIVIZED, then calmly discuss what WE should do:

  • What WE should ALLOW people to own.
  • What WE should ALLOW people to do.
  • What WE should ALLOW people to say.
  • How WE should ALLOW people to use their property.
  • How WE should ALLOW people to conduct their businesses,
  • … and WHO should be ALLOWED,
  • … and WHERE.
  • How WE should ALLOW people to raise their children.
  • Who should be GIVEN which roles within society.
  • etc.

The issue under discussion is always something sympathetic, something most decent people would like to see fixed: intergenerational poverty, police brutality, environmental degradation, bigotry, violence.

But the solutions modern communists put forward are rarely passive, and they are never liberating. If a problem can be solved by individual action, voluntary charity, by the free market, or by the passage of time, that is never seen as good enough. In fact, nothing that fails to increase the power and control of governments or certain institutions (or to grow the people’s dependence on them) is ever regarded as a solution at all.

The people who do the work of modern communism, debating and voting on these “issues of the day” are mostly not aware of what they are doing. A majority of them are decent people who want real problems addressed. But their thinking is confined to a multiple choice question presented by prestige media and schools where only oppressive proposals are listed as options.

Even those higher up the food chain, the ones who create the policy proposals or set the bounds of debate around them are not usually conscious of the way they are manipulating the public. They are hobbled by a theory of history (care of the school system) where the past is merely a series of dragons slain by government policy, where everything is “systemic”, and where the free choices and conscientious actions of individuals have no meaningful effect.

This is how the enemy operates

In order for modern communists to have the latitude to execute their plans, they need every citizen to be as weak and dependent as possible. They especially need the middle tiers of management, professions, and bureaucracy to be filled with minimally competent placeholders who owe their position to political and institutional favor. These sorts of people, since they are only able to achieve their present position through the system, are more pliable to coercion and less likely to see freedom in any aspect of life as promising or beneficial.


As a consequence, modern communists wage eternal war against every wholesome and sustainable aspect of life, society, and culture which gives people or communities strength and independence. They see it as desirable to destroy the natural optimum which people discover through freedom and competition and replace it with fragile, orchid-like solutions which could not thrive without government and/or institutional intervention:

  • Those with demonstrable skills must be replaced by those with credentials.
  • The self-employed must be reduced to the status of employees.
  • Property must become regulated or burdened with tax and debt, and wherever possible, wealth must be rendered intangible as abstracted financial fictions constructed of laws.
  • People must come to rely on government programs for security where they previously relied on themselves and each other.
  • The traditional family and organic communities it forms, such as churches, must be invaded, defanged, and delegitimized to leave people at the mercy of authorities.

To a modern communist, “freedom” means the opportunity for individuals to choose some fundamentally maladaptive way of life and be protected from consequences, encouraged and subsidized by power.

The weaker you are, the more useful you are to those in power. Those who choose to be weak and dependent where they could be healthy and independent are collaborators.

This is what I see happening

The American public has come to accept all the components of totalitarian states.

  • We have come to accept a militarized police.
  • We have come to accept ideological indoctrination in schools.
  • We have come to accept mass surveillance.
  • We have come to accept speech codes.
  • We have come to accept the rewriting of history to serve the interests of the ruling party.
  • We have come to accept the tarring of political dissidents as “terrorists”, “extremists”, and “White Supremacists.”
  • We have come to accept the State telling us when and where we can meet.
  • We have come to accept the State shutting down our places of worship.
  • We have come to accept the idea that parents should have no special authority over their children.
  • We have come to accept the manipulation of thought through the manipulation of language.
  • We have come to accept the radical reordering of society by government in the name of crisis.

In the 2016 election, the full-throated manipulation by the mainstream press, academia, and the political establishment was so intense, and so obvious, that many people (myself included) who did not consider themselves “conservative” voted for Donald Trump just to poke a finger in the eye of Leviathan. So many people did so that his margin of victory exceeded the margin of cheat, and he was actually able to become president. …

Now, in the 2020 election, the fraud and manipulation became so glaringly obvious that, at the time of writing, at least 47% of all Americans, regardless of party loyalty, understand that the election was stolen and Joe Biden is illegitimate. Somehow though, it is still a long shot that Donald Trump, the person who has done more to expose the mendacity and incompetence of the ruling party and institutions than anyone else, will be seated as President.

Every one of those Americans who understands this must realize that this is it. This is the last moment for the American Republic, the last time we will even have a glimmer of a chance of an honest election result, and the last time any opposition to modern communism will be afforded space in the public square. And yet, neither I nor most of you are going to do anything about this situation that might risk our present status or comfort.

This is why I won’t yet act

Unfortunately for me, the crisis has come either too late or too early. Our family has four young children, a single income, and a base of assets which could be easily lost but probably never replaced. We are maximally vulnerable to the sorts of attacks which collectivists bring against those who fight back. …

When I look around me, I see many people who are paralyzed as I am. We know that the fight for our republic is unavoidable, and that the time is now, but do not see a nucleus of resistance to which we can pledge our lives, fortunes, and sacred honors without it being tantamount to suicide. We are watching and waiting for someone else to be that nucleus.

If you have the courage to act where I do not, here is what I WILL do:

  • If you speak out against them, I will listen.
  • If you act against them, I will not stand in your way.
  • If they portray you as uncool, cringey, old-fashioned, unintelligent, or low-class, I will not laugh at you or think less of you.
  • If they call you a racist, sexist, xenophobe, homophobe, Nazi, granny killer, etc., I will not believe them, nor will I care.
  • If they call you a terrorist or an extremist, I will not assume that you are in the wrong.
  • When they ask me questions, I will lie, forget, or evade as I am able.
  • When they tell me their version of history, I will smile and nod and know they are liars.
  • If they dispossess you, I will share what I can.
  • If they martyr you, my children will learn your name as that of a hero.
  • If you have the courage to be shameless in opposing them, you will be honored in my house.


  1. Very good Ed.
    A very good realist comment, and brings a deeper understanding of the problems up against us.
    It explains some of our reticence, like using pseudonyms.

    There is a point, she is even if quiet, a point of the resistance.
    Like just being a safe house, resupply,
    Being able to help, even if surreptitiously.
    That allows others to extend themselves further if need be, in challenging questioning authoritative bureaucracy and representatives.

    That needs to be respected too, as often one does not know just how far people actually do risk things, in other ways, than how you do, and take flak over other issues,

    The quietness, is because one can not trust others, but the worst part, even the ones you back & support, because they talk too much, believe you should be more gung-ho, and evangelistic, impose on you, which can prove personally very costly, for no real gain.
    Yet those quiet backers will often take some risk to do what they can.

    It is good to know they are out there, even in New Zealand. Thanks Ed.
    So even if quiet, do what we can in support of the challengers, and where possible to challenge the ‘Political class, of bureau-expert-techno-crats.
    So the people, the populism, the nationalists, still build up to make MNZGA.
    and change the “uni” party system.



  2. Thanks Ed.

    Excellent piece. I like the way the writer has “modernised” the description of communism , away from the grey images of Eastern Europe 50 years ago. Her personal honesty is to be applauded.
    I will spread it around , as much as I can, as it deserves a wide audience and I would encourage others to do the same.



  3. ‘The people who do the work are mostly unaware of what they are doing.’

    This is so true .I am amazed at the people I know who are totally absorbed in the ‘system’ and can’t see it.

    I want to write to a CE but feel if I signed my name I would be in for bashing. It’s what they do. No thinking ,no analysis ,no brain.

    Oh and I’m not qualified so would not count.



  4. So well written.
    Despite the length, not a word wasted.

    To pick a winner – in agreement with wiseowl above – I would emphasise the key paragraph:-

    ‘The people who do the work of modern communism, debating and voting on these “issues of the day” are mostly not aware of what they are doing. A majority of them are decent people who want real problems addressed. But their thinking is confined to a multiple choice question presented by prestige media and schools where only oppressive proposals are listed as options.’

    I know several people who have woken to this in 2020 when they see the tyranny and actions completely against logic.
    I think the slow boiling the frog that has gone on for years was really accelerated in 2020 with Covid scare-mongering, lockdowns, business (livelihood) disruption and annihilation; promoting BLM and XR destruction (lets not call them protests)

    The irony in this is , like so much doublespeak, the term woke means the opposite.
    The ‘woke’ are mindless foot soldiers fighting a battle they do not understand….on the wrong side (per moi opinion)

    She correctly identifies the Triad we are against.
    para above ‘presented by prestige media and schools ‘
    1. schools, 2. media, and 3. stasi enforcement.
    The Triad.
    The politicians are subordinate to them now.



  5. Good to know I’m not alone but the truth of this post is heartbreaking really. I never imagined I would live in a world where every communication I make would have to be weighed against possible personal risk. Welcome to a world where facts are subjective. Having believed and argued all my life that people should be judged by their actions, not the colour of their skin, their gender, or where they come from, it’s really gut-wrenching to have failed so miserably. Truth and reason are being destroyed by identity politics and MSM, purveyors all, of exactly the schisms we fought against.

    Anyone with any life experience, can see where all this division ends up. When hard-working, law-abiding taxpayers are forced to fund beliefs they neither agree with nor benefit from and feel unsafe to protest, those that can leave will and the rest of us will reduce outputs to the barest minimum. Where is the incentive to contribute to a society that, not only does not celebrate your efforts, but favours those who do not contribute at all? Schisms that owe their very existence to the indulgence of taxpayers but add nothing to the wealth or well-being of the country, will be forced to compete for ever-scarcer funds. Inevitably they must turn on eachother. Meanwhile, the capable unblinkered, sick of funding their nonsense, but feeling unsafe to criticise, have cashed up and retired early. They have built themselves lovely new houses with over the top security and every conceivable comfort. They sit on huge wads of cash and assets, real estate here and abroad, gold and metals, art, stamps, antiques and collectibles, cars, boats etc while they await the return of sanity.

    With that withdrawal of participation, we must continue to import the gullible and desperate to make up the shortfall in the tax-take. How stupid they must think NZ that we would would allow shop workers, hairdressers, take-away cooks etc to be classed as skilled migrants? That enrolment in the most basic tertiary course will buy them and their extended families citizenship? That NZ education providers are so desperate for funds they would design courses specifically to increase a student’s immigration points. Courses designed solely for them. As we are now seeing, without immigrants there is no call for those courses. What do these immigrants think when the penny drops and they realise they have only been imported through necessity, not kindness? That any migrant with real skills will have at least 3 countries of preference for citizenship above NZ? One imagines the best of our immigrants don’t take long to realise that the NZ nirvana they hoped for is far more of a nightmare and buggar off

    Personally, I would far rather be making more money than hunkering down but it really sticks in my craw that in doing so I would be paying the expense accounts of those that openly despise me. I never thought for a minute that the people whose equality and freedom that I always defended would so vehemently deny those same freedoms to me.



    • Well said on your points Coral

      you say
      ‘Where is the incentive to contribute to a society that, not only does not celebrate your efforts, but favours those who do not contribute at all? ‘

      That is the whole point
      Communists in ‘Be Kind’ masks !

      True masks that mask who they really are- to the majority.
      The mask wearing has been longer than just this year.

      Communism is exactly : ‘Where is the incentive to contribute to a society’ as you say.

      Good assessment on school/tertiary/fake tertiary

      Reread my comment above on the Triad.
      The three arms working against you.
      This includes education sector.
      They have uses BS courses to built up their war-chest….
      …and war it is, make no mistake.

      The pen is mightier than the sword.
      The media use this and the sheeple suck it up.

      If those two don’t get you (kids repeating crap they are force fed at school for example, mainly lies) then the stasi are in line to take you down.
      Dob in a neighbour today.
      There was a trial run in NZ on dobbing in your neighbour ; earlier this year.

      Politicians cannot help you as they have been displaced.
      Even B Hussein Obummer was a pure puppet with no real power.
      Johnny Key was the same.

      The Notional mob of girly men and bible bashers are not there for you .
      The only opposition they do is opposition to your well-being.
      Eg supporting gun laws against legitimate NZ citizens who did nothing wrong on 15 03 19
      The support of Carbon crime legislation – then daftly saying they will reverse it ‘when in Govt.’
      There was fraud right there. They don’t reverse Labour stuff .

      Notional are the Opposition.
      Opposition to you.
      The sell out will be complete on 20 01 2021 unless a major intervention event occurs.

      The Die is set.



    • A great summation of how a lot of us are feeling CoralSea. Thanks for posting.

      Given the situation, and the futile feeling it enables, the question is – whatever are we going to do about it?

      The same ones too busy working to stand around all day protesting this that and the next thing. Too busy being good little slaves, providing the productivity to keep the ferals fed, clothed, pissed and addled. We can only take it in our stride for so long……someone’s going to snap.



Recent posts

COVID Vaccine Injuries Compensation

COVID Vaccine Injuries Quietly Being Compensated Around The World Written by Jennifer Margulis and Joe Wang Programs in countries around the world have begun quietly compensating...

More Evidence Of Covid Vaccine Effects

Thousands of Jabbed Teenage Girls Are Developing Tics, Doctors Baffled Thousands of fully jabbed teenage girls in Australia are being struck down by a mystery...

Be Prepared

FEMA Warns US To Prepare For 10 Years Off Electricity Grid After ‘Perfect Solar Storm’ A perfect solar storm similar to one that slammed into...

Recent comments

The Ancient Hooligan on Have Your Say
The Ancient Hooligan on Have Your Say
Pinky1 on Have Your Say
I am a stupid boy on Have Your Say
Brigadier General Rissole on Have Your Say
Tarquin on Have Your Say
Brigadier General Rissole on Have Your Say
Brigadier General Rissole on Have Your Say

The way we all feel about this useless government

overcast clouds
6.2 ° C
8.5 °
6.2 °
96 %
99 %
8 °
13 °
13 °
12 °
12 °
NZD - New Zealand Dollar